Pizza is great and the dinners are Fantastic! Large portions and fair prices are just a bonus, the food is the Star!

Sergio's is the finest restaurant in town! I went in with my friend for supper and my oh my was it excellent! The pizza man, Marlo bauer handed me the food directly... it was fantastic and delicious. I love the atmosphere, fantastic prices despite Joe Biden and his acts that lead to terrible inflation. I'm so excited to return next weekend after I hit the galf course! WE LOVE SERGIOS!

Great value for money! My very picky husband liked it and he's a pizza snob. I found the gluten free pizza weirdly fluffy. I was not a fan but I do appreciate that it's not the grainy rice cracker most places want to offer.

Food is good, whether dinners, pizza or catering. Like all restaurants in Hamden, it's something like 20% higher in price than the surrounding area. Don't know why I can't get a couple pizzas and a salad for less than $80. Service is iffy on the phone sometimes, but they deliver well.

In my first review I wrote I can't wait to come back to try more items on the menu. So we stop back for lunch. We started off with an order of their wedding soup, and a meatball grinder. We also took home their carrot cake and tiramisu. Dessert portions were huge.Everything was delicious, and you can tell everything here is homemade.

After a long day at work the fam surprised me with a Lobster Ravioli dinner from Sergio's last week! What?! Shrimp grilled to perfection on top,the ravioli was stuffed with lobster and the creamy pink sauce was smooth and perfectly seasoned! Salad was fresh, bread was plentiful and must be shop made! Just enough to dip in the sauce! No butter needed! Beautiful dinner!

Have been back twice since first review. I'm glad that this business survived the pandemic and rash reviews written during it like my last one. The owner reached out to make it right, I declined. I made it back twice on my own since. The last time we ate in and it was fantastic! Steak sandwich, fries, eggplant pizza, and pasta and meatballs. The pizza was especially tasty, the crust crisp, the sauce tangy, good quality cheese. All food was quite good and the prices quite fair. A combination that's very hard to find these days. Will definitely be back with my family. I really like that you pay after ordering and get your own plates and utensils. This model speeds up service. Everyone was pleasant and courteous, even though it was very busy.

We were on an ice cream quest on a Friday night, so naturally, we had to add pizza into the mix. Went into Sergio's without looking up any reviews on Yelp (normally a dangerous move). Although they weren't technically serving anyone, their tables were available to sit at, so we ordered mozz sticks (phenomenal cheese inside) and a large half bacon/half meatball. The mozz sticks came out very quickly and then the pizza came out. We stared at it like a groom doing a first look at the bride . The crust was perfectly cooked and the toppings were plentiful. Add Foxon Park, homemade cookies and friendly staff into the equation and you get return customers! Also, Wentworth's Ice Cream is about a 25 second drive away

I've been going to Sergios since they opened more than 15 years ago. Their pizza is delicious. Their regular menu items are delicious. The cookies. Well, the cookies are made by a local baker and are hard to come by because they sell out so quickly. I haven't been able to get kitchen sink cookies for, well, I can't remember the last time it's been so long. So, aside from that disappointment, and that they only had 3 packages of oatmeal raisin cookies today (I always buy chocolate chip), the food just doesn't disappoint. The dining room is closed until Summer but that shouldn't stop you from going in to see all the other wonderful desserts they have when you pick up your food/pizza!